The Lady in Question 1940

The jury finds her innocent... well not too innocent!

6.6 / 10   22 vote(s)
NR
Romance Comedy Drama

When a jury member takes in the defendant he couldn't convict, she has a bad influence on his son.

Release Date 1940-08-07
Runtime 1h 20m
Directors Charles Vidor, Lucien N. Andriot
Producer B.B. Kahane
Writers Marcel Achard, Jan Lustig

Brian Aherne is quite good in this comedy drama. He is an enthusiastic juror who having convinced his colleagues to acquit "Natalie" (Rita Hayworth) of a charge of murder after she attempted to extort money from her beau, offers her a job in his family bicycle shop. He keeps her identity secret. Soon his son "Pierre" (Glenn Ford) is really pretty smitten and their normally ordered life starts to become a little bit hectic. At times, this is really quite enjoyable - Aherne is on good form (he reminded me a bit of Robert Donat), with a quickly paced script and a few red herrings about the girl's guilt or innocence to keep the plot interesting. The ending is a little bit contrived, but it is still not a bad reimagining of "Gribouille" (1937).

CinemaSerf